I’ve misplaced rely of the variety of things we reviewed this yr at Engadget. In 2024, the varieties of merchandise we examined ranged from the standard telephones, laptops and headphones to AI wearables, robotic lawnmowers and handheld gaming consoles, alongside games and shows. It may well really feel exhausting to maintain monitor of all of it, however fortunately, our scoring system helps us spotlight the very best (and the worst) units annually.
Our workforce of reviewers and editors consider merchandise primarily based on their efficiency, worth and the way they maintain up towards the competitors, and at the very least two folks weigh in on each rating earlier than it is revealed. If one thing will get a results of 80 and up, it is thought of a “Really helpful” product, whereas these scoring 90 and extra are awarded “Editors’ Alternative.” The latter means they’re the very best of their class, beating out a lot of the competitors.
Since we now have to be very even handed about what we evaluation (there’s solely a lot time on the planet), a lot of the devices we name in are from established firms with a monitor report of creating issues folks will really contemplate shopping for. That is the primary motive most of our scores sit between 80 and 90, although we nonetheless take a look at the occasional machine that finally ends up getting a quantity beneath 70.
As we glance again on the yr in devices, listed here are the 12 highest-scored opinions we revealed. Unsurprisingly, they’re largely of Apple and Google merchandise, with a smattering of cameras and drones. I am additionally together with some honorable mentions for good measure, in addition to a pair of the lowest-rated units all yr. Could we now have solely glorious devices to evaluation subsequent yr, and should there be much less e-waste throughout.
With a refined design, much-improved telephoto digicam and nice battery-life, the Pixel 9 Professional cements its standing because the smartphone with the very best digicam.
- Nice digicam options and improved telephoto digicam
- A yr of Gemini Superior totally free
- Unimaginable battery life
- An exquisite, shiny display screen that’s straightforward to make use of outside
- Tensor G4 runs cooler than its predecessor
- Slower charging speeds than the XL
- Not the very best cellphone for gaming
With much more helpful images tips and a much-improved telephoto digicam, the Pixel 9 Professional XL cements its standing as the very best smartphone digicam.
- Nice digicam options and improved telephoto digicam
- A yr of Gemini Superior totally free
- Spectacular battery life
- An exquisite, shiny display screen that’s straightforward to make use of outside
- Tensor G4 runs cooler than its predecessor
- Costlier than final yr’s Pixel 8 Professional
- Not an amazing gaming cellphone
- Somewhat unwieldy
Pixel 9 Professional and Pixel 9 Professional XL
I am actually shocked. For the primary time in years, we have given a Google cellphone the next rating than an iPhone in the identical yr. Perhaps it has one thing to do with Gemini AI launching sooner than Apple Intelligence, or the enjoyable colours and stable construct of the Pixel 9 Pro series. However as I mentioned the scores with our reviewer Mat Smith, a couple of issues added up. Arguably the largest benefit Google has over Apple this yr is battery life — the Pixel 9 Professionals typically final about two days on a cost, whereas the iPhone 16 Professional collection usually clocks simply round 20 hours. We additionally love Google’s cameras and the intense, clean shows. The beautiful palette of pastel coloration choices is simply icing on a satisfying cake, with Gemini AI bringing a tasty facet deal with.
DJI / Engadget
The Avata 2 improves nearly the whole lot from the very talked-about unique whereas shaving some {dollars} off the price
- Improved video high quality
- Higher maneuverability
- Cheaper
- Longer battery life
- Goggles 3 could lack consolation for some
DJI Avata 2
Although there’s looming concern over DJI’s longevity in the US, the corporate has in any other case had a comparatively profitable 2024. This yr noticed many DJI merchandise scoring greater than 90 in our database, which is sensible as they’re arguably the very best drone maker round. Steve was most impressed by the Avata 2, although, due to its nice video high quality and maneuverability for a cheaper price than its predecessor. It even has higher battery life, as well.
Apple / Engadget
The iPhone 16 Professional Max affords glorious cameras and enhancing instruments, a big roomy display screen, lengthy battery life and the very best that Apple has to supply.
Editors’ observe: The present rating displays our expertise with the {hardware} and iOS 18 options that might be out there to customers at launch. We’ll consider Apple Intelligence and different post-launch options over the approaching weeks and months, and should alter our evaluation rating if warranted.
- Glorious cameras with minimal shutter lag
- Lengthy-lasting battery
- Nice picture and video enhancing updates
- Good customization choices all through
- Digital camera management is not good
Apple / Engadget
The iPhone 16 Professional is a good flagship with glorious, quick cameras and enhancing instruments. However chances are you’ll must cost it greater than as soon as to final all day.
Editors’ observe: The present rating displays our expertise with the {hardware} and iOS 18 options that might be out there to customers at launch. We’ll consider Apple Intelligence and different post-launch options over the approaching weeks and months, and should alter our evaluation rating if warranted.
- Quick digicam with top quality video seize
- Photographic kinds are efficient and fairly
- Good customizations out there all through
- Comparatively quick battery life
- Digital camera Management is not good
iPhone 16 Professional and iPhone 16 Professional Max
Apple Intelligence wasn’t out there when the iPhone 16 collection launched and only recently rolled out, so our evaluation rating may nonetheless change, However as it’s, and after months of utilizing the iPhone 16 Professional and Professional Max in my day by day life, I stand by my analysis. Although there’s lots to love about Apple’s newest flagships, I used to be simply so disenchanted by the comparatively poor battery life that I couldn’t rating it larger than the Pixel 9 Professional collection. That is extra noticeable on the iPhone 16 Professional, although, because the Professional Max typically lasts a couple of extra hours than its smaller counterpart. I additionally want the generative-AI options have been prepared for the general public on the time of my review, however now that I’ve spent extra time with Genmoji, Picture Playground and notification summaries, I am fairly positive my verdict stays the identical. These Apple Intelligence options are enjoyable, however not game-changing, and with or with out them the iPhone 16 Professional and Professional Max are nonetheless the very best choices for anybody on iOS.
Canon
The EOS R5 II is Canon’s finest digicam in years due to enhancements in key areas like autofocus and video.
- Quick taking pictures speeds
- Canon’s finest autofocus but
- Highly effective video capabilities
- Good picture stabilization
- Nonetheless overheats for high-res video
Canon EOS R5 II
We have got a slew of opinions by Steve on this record, largely for merchandise in cameras and drones that ranked nicely of their classes. As a Canon lady myself, I used to be pleased to see the EOS R5 II get such a very good score, particularly since competitors has been heating up. Sadly, the EOS R5 II additionally heats up when taking pictures high-res video, however on just about each different side, it performs respectably. In line with Steve, this digicam “places Sony on discover,” and I am glad to see it.
Sony
Sony’s A9 III is the primary mainstream digicam with an modern international shutter, which is quick with minimal picture distortion. Nevertheless it ends in diminished picture high quality in comparison with common CMOS cameras.
- Extremely fast
- Quick and correct autofocus
- Good stabilization
- Glorious video capaibilities
- Lowered picture high quality
- Costly
Sony A9 III
Reviewed a lot earlier within the yr, the Sony A9 III caught Steve’s consideration for its speedy international shutter, which introduced quick and correct autofocus. It additionally delivered clean, high-quality video in a physique with glorious dealing with due to Sony’s comfy new grip. Steve additionally cherished the viewfinder, and although it is very costly at $6,000, the A9 III is a stable product that holds the title of “fastest full-frame camera” — at the very least, till one thing quicker comes alongside.
DJI
DJI’s Air 3S is the corporate’s first client drone with LiDAR designed to make it safer to fly at evening.
- Glorious picture high quality
- LiDAR improves impediment detection at evening
- ActiveTrack 360 produces cinematic monitoring pictures
- Lengthy battery life
- Now has 42GB inner storage
- Generally fails to detect small obstacles
DJI
The DJI Neo could also be an affordable, beginner-friendly drone, however has highly effective options like topic monitoring and fast pictures.
- Fast and maneuverable
- Cheap
- Contains high-end options
- Newbie pleasant
- No vertical video
- Appears like a banshee
- Prime speeds require particular controller
DJI Air 3S and DJI Neo
What light-weight $200 drone shoots good 1080p video but in addition screams like a banshee? That may be the DJI Neo, which, regardless of Steve’s evocative description, is one thing I am contemplating shopping for for myself. Not solely is it moderately priced, but it surely additionally guarantees to seize clean aerial footage at a decent decision. Steve additionally discovered it beginner-friendly, which is essential for a awful pilot like me. And positive, perhaps I am going to scare some wildlife or neighbors with its loud screeching, however perhaps that is a part of the enjoyable?
If you would like one thing that may keep away from folks or obstacles and ship cinematic pictures, the DJI Air 3S is a stable possibility due to its LiDAR and bigger digicam sensor, each of which enhance efficiency and obstacle-detection in low gentle. You may need to pay about 5 instances the Neo’s price, in fact, however aspiring Spielbergs may discover that value worthwhile.
Apple
Apple’s 14-inch MacBook Professional is best than ever due to its M4 chips, Thunderbolt 5 assist and barely brighter screens.
- Quick M4 chips
- Brighter show
- Sharp 12MP Heart Stage webcam
- Thunderbolt 5 with M4 Professional/Max
- Lengthy battery life
Apple
Apple’s 16-inch MacBook Professional is best than ever due to its M4 chips, Thunderbolt 5 assist and barely brighter screens.
- Quick M4 chips
- Brighter show
- Sharp 12MP Heart Stage webcam
- Thunderbolt 5 with M4 Professional/Max
- Lengthy battery life
MacBook Professional (14-inch, 2024) and MacBook Professional (16-inch, 2024)
I am not stunned that the one laptops to make it to this record are this year’s M4 MacBook Pros. Apple has demonstrated over the previous few years that its M-series processors ship glorious efficiency and battery life, and it is continued to show its level in 2024. This yr’s mannequin options brighter screens and improved webcams, in addition to slight bumps in RAM and storage. I am a Home windows consumer, however even I’ve to confess that what Apple is doing with the MacBooks is one thing that Microsoft and all its companions on the PC facet have struggled to totally replicate.
ASUS / Engadget
For anybody who desires sturdy efficiency in a conveyable design, the ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 is each pound for pound and greenback for greenback your best option round.
- Lovely understated design
- Attractive OLED display screen
- Sturdy efficiency
- Good port choice
- Punchy audio system
- Backside vents can get a bit toasty
- Keyboard solely has single-zone lighting
- Armoury Crate app is type of messy
- RAM is soldered in
ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 (2024)
What PC makers do excel at is energy and creativity. When it isn’t experimenting with dual-screen laptops, ASUS is pushing out succesful gaming laptops in its Republic of Avid gamers (ROG) model. This yr, our reviewer Sam Rutherford’s top-scored product is the ROG Zephyrus G14, which he declared “the 14-inch gaming laptop computer to beat.” Sam hasn’t given out the next rating in any respect this yr, so it stands to motive we now have but to see a gaming pocket book steal that crown. The Zephyrus G14 received Sam over with its stunning OLED display screen, engaging but refined design and beneficiant array of ports. Although he isn’t a fan of its soldered-in RAM and ASUS’ Armoury Crate app, Sam nonetheless discovered lots to love, calling it “each pound for pound and greenback for greenback your best option round.”
There are many merchandise which may have obtained the identical rating because the ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 and iPhone 16 Professional, however we now have to chop the record someplace. It is value mentioning that different units we awarded a rating of 91 embody the DJI Osmo Pocket 3, the Analogue Duo, the Fujifilm X100 VI and the iPad Air (2024). And in terms of issues that acquired 90 factors, we have the bottom iPhone 16 and iPhone 16 Plus, the Apple Watch Series 10, NVIDIA’s RTX 4070 Super graphics card, the Meta Quest 3S headset, in addition to home equipment like Ninja’s Creami ice-cream maker.
However I needed to shout out Daniel Cooper’s review of the reMarkable Paper Pro. It is a gadget that is introduced again waves of nostalgia and sentimentality in a time after we’re all bored with always being wired in. It is one of many highest-rated merchandise of its form, not solely as a result of it is a succesful writing pill, but in addition as a result of it’s a coloration e-paper pill that has an even bigger display screen and quicker efficiency than its monochrome predecessor. At $580 to start out, it is definitely a major funding, however one which may free us from feeling chained to our laptops and telephones.
Worst merchandise we reviewed this yr: Humane AI Pin and Rabbit R1
In all my 8-plus years at Engadget, I can solely bear in mind one different time we have awarded something a sub-60 rating, and that was when Fisher-Price’s Sproutling wearable baby monitor gave our editor’s child an eczema outbreak. The Sproutling acquired an appropriately all-time low rating of 41, and this yr, the Rabbit R1 broke that backside when Devindra determined it deserved solely 40 factors.
The Rabbit R1 first made waves at CES 2024, when it confirmed up out of nowhere and enticed many people with its cute appears to be like and shiny orange coloration. Its Teenage Engineering heritage was much more alluring, and all of us needed to check out the Playdate-esque scroll wheel for ourselves. The sq. machine additionally got here with an onboard digicam, two microphones, rotating digicam and a 2.88-inch show. However its greatest promise was, as with the whole lot in 2024, all about AI.
And with many issues in 2024, the AI promise fell flat. Rabbit made daring claims about its “giant motion mannequin,” however in reality, on the time of our evaluation, the R1 might barely execute duties to completion. As an alternative of letting you simply make orders through DoorDash, for instance, it might “usually ship the climate once I requested for visitors,” based on Devindra’s evaluation. Worse, “typically it might hear my request and easily do nothing.”
I had a equally irritating expertise when testing the much-hyped Humane AI Pin. It was a shiny chrome sq. that you might connect to your garments and work together with both by voice, contact or through a futuristic-looking projector that beamed a show onto your palm. You have been supposed to have the ability to merely discuss to the Humane AI assistant to get it to recollect issues for and about you, ultimately coming to depend on it like a second mind.
As an alternative, we acquired a sizzling mess. Fairly actually. The Humane AI Pin would continuously run so sizzling that it might cease working, with the machine saying it wanted to chill down for a bit earlier than you might use it once more. When it did work, it was barely sensible sufficient to reply questions, and although the projector was cool visually, utilizing it to do something was irritating and simply led to sore arms and crossed eyes. Not solely did it not do sufficient to justify the hassle concerned in utilizing it, the Humane AI Pin additionally price $700 — manner an excessive amount of for a product this finicky.
It will get worse (or higher, relying on the way you’re studying this). Shortly after it was extensively criticized by reviewers in April, leaked internal documents showed that folks seemed to be returning the AI Pins quicker than the corporate was promoting them. In October, Humane needed to issue a recall for its charging case due to overheating, with the Client Product Security Fee saying it posed “a fireplace hazard.”
I gave the Humane AI Pin a rating of fifty in my evaluation, largely as a result of intriguing projector show. Proper now, although, it appears these AI devices are, at finest, struggling to take maintain. At worst, they’re on fireplace.
Trending Merchandise
